Luxury An Idiot’s Guide to the Top Lots at the Phillips Heuer Auction Grade 1 Replica Watches

Heuer Autavia 2446M Big Sub 1

Being effectively polished as a men’s thing is something that TAG Heuer got right from the Link, and in a number of respects, I can’t think of a lot of other truly contemporary men’s dressy company necklace watches that are this boldly glistening and yet nonetheless elegantly tasteful. The hour markers and hands can manage to be so big because the remainder of the dial is relatively uncluttered and clean. I would however have enjoyed the date disc’s color to match that of the main dial (although it does on versions such as the Link with all the black dial). I’d have also enjoyed for the 12 o’clock hour mark to be slightly different in design from the remainder of the hour markers. This is a frequent practice which is appreciated because it helps the viewer’s mind orientate the dial up when looking at it from various angles. Possessing a distinctive-looking 12 o’clock hour mark just overall assists with legibility, but also orientates the layout so that it has a proper “up” and “down.” It may have been enough for them to simply create the 12 o’clock hour marker a little wider, as well as an applied version of this TAG Heuer logo. Also given the size of the hands and hour mark, I bet that this watch dial would look cool with tritium gas tubes (OK, now I am just going beyond what the manufacturer would even do).

Long the poor cousin of Rolex and Omega collecting, vintage Heuer watches are now in demand. The milestone event for the genre takes place in mid November when Phillips will sell over 40 chronographs from the collections of Richard Crosthwaite and Paul Gavin, a pair of English Heuer enthusiasts who have written two books on the subject.

Properly titled The Crosthwaite & Gavin Collection: Exceptional Heuer Chronographs from the Jack Heuer Era, the auction has been a long time coming, with the run-up over the last three years having seen a spike in values and interest. Just in June 2017 Christie’s sold an Autavia bearing the logo of the Indianapolis Motor Speedway for US$199,5000. The success is thanks to a combination of savvy promotion by TAG Heuer chief executive Jean-Claude Biver as well as lots of exposure in vintage-focused watch sites like Hodinkee.

Heuer chronographs from the 1960s to 1970s – the last era of Heuer family ownership that ended with the Quartz Crisis – have proven to be the most desirable. The Heuer auction is consequently arranged around that period, with 42 vintage watches plus one modern limited edition that’ll be sold for charity. Here’s a look at five of them.

Lot 3 – Heuer Autavia ref. 2446M “Big Sub” 

Perhaps the watch that will end up being the most expensive in the sale, this is an early Autavia ref. 2446 dating from 1962. Extraordinarily, this is a watch that was selling for well under US$5000 ten years ago, and well under US$10,000 five years ago – and in December 2016 Christie’s sold a similar watch for US$125,000.

What makes this Autavia desirable is the “first execution” dial, characterised by the oversized chronograph registers.

Heuer Autavia 2446M Big Sub 1

The hands are “second execution”, with luminous fill down the middle, setting them apart from the “first execution” hands that are covered with luminous paint edge to edge.

Heuer Autavia 2446M Big Sub 3

Heuer Autavia 2446M Big Sub 2

Another feature distinct to earlier examples are the smaller pushers and crown with a domed top.

Heuer Autavia 2446M Big Sub 4

The reason this watch might end up being the top lot is two-fold. First is its intrinsic rarity, being an early example, and the second is the fact that the Autavia has evolved into the most desirable Heuer model.

Heuer Autavia 2446M Big Sub 5

A contraction of “automobile” and “aviation”, the Autavia encapsulates all of Heuer’s prowess as a maker of stopwatches for professionals. A later version of the ref. 2646 was the first model subject to a modern remake when Jean-Claude Biver took charge of the company, and the Autavia line the focus of a lengthy book, which now makes the model almost the signature Heuer watch.

This is estimated at SFr80,000 to SFr120,000.

Lot 6 – Heuer Monaco ref. 740.303N “Dark Lord”

The next lot stands in stark contrast to the Autavia ref. 2446 above. Once the most expensive of vintage Heuer watches – it peaked at about US$75,000 – the “Dark Lord” was the holy grail for many collectors when Heuer was still an esoteric pursuit.

Heuer Monaco 740.303N Dark Lord 1

Now that the brand has become more mainstream, it has been eclipsed by other Heuer chronographs, since they are regarded as more historically important and also round in shape, a quality that draws greater mass appeal.

Heuer Monaco 740.303N Dark Lord 2

Heuer Monaco 740.303N Dark Lord 6

Once believed to have been a small series of prototypes, Phillips says some 100 to 200 may exist, according to the recollections of Jack Heuer. According to lore, Mr Heuer ordered up a black Monaco after seeing a black-coated Audemars Piguet Royal Oak on the wrist of the King of Spain.

Heuer Monaco 740.303N Dark Lord 5

Heuer Monaco 740.303N Dark Lord 3

Heuer Monaco 740.303N Dark Lord 4

The black and orange colours along with the aged tritium make this an extremely striking watch, and this example is in “new old stock” condition, with a pristine black powder coating (usually extremely delicate) as well as its box and paperwork. The estimate is SFr35,000 to SFr50,000.

Lot 39 – Heuer Carrera ref. 1158CHN “Ferrari”

Nicknamed the “Ferrari” watch because it was the model Jack Heuer handed out to Ferrari drivers as part of the watchmaker’s sponsorship of the racing team, the Carrera ref. 1158 has an 18k gold case and was the most expensive Heuer in its time, especially when paired with the matching 18k gold bracelet.

Heuer Carrera 1158CHN Ferrari 1

Heuer Carrera 1158CHN Ferrari 4

Heuer Carrera 1158CHN Ferrari 5

This example is the rarest and best looking version of the ref. 1158, with black sub-dials and date – the suffix “CHN” is short for chronographe noir. In fact, a unique variant of the ref. 1158 CHN that was one of Jack Heuer’s gifts to a driver still holds the record for the most expensive Heuer ever sold at auction, having sold for about US$230,000 at Sotheby’s last year.

Heuer Carrera 1158CHN Ferrari 3

Heuer Carrera 1158CHN Ferrari 2

But despite being rare and intrinsically valuable because of the precious metal, the ref. 1158 is nowhere near as valuable as the top-end Autavia chronographs, which is a repeat of the trend for collectible Rolex and Omega chronographs. The no-frills steel models, ostensibly made for professionals, are always the first to take off in value, while the luxe versions tend take longer to creep upwards.

Consequently, it is relatively affordable as such things go, with an estimate of SFr15,000 to SFr25,000.

Lot 40 – Heuer Monaco ref. 1133B “Steve McQueen”

Having got its name by virtue of the fact that the actor wore one in the 1971 film Le Mans, the Heuer Monaco ref. 1133B was arguably the signature Heuer until the Autavia took prominence.

Heuer Monaco 1133B Steve McQueen 7

The blue dial, horizontal baton markers and square case are distinctly 1970s, yet still attractive today, a quality few watches of that era possess.

Heuer Monaco 1133B Steve McQueen 2

Heuer Monaco 1133B Steve McQueen 1

And unlike many other comparable watches that are desirable for their provenance and history, the Monaco has a movement that is historically significant.

Heuer Monaco 1133B Steve McQueen 5

Heuer Monaco 1133B Steve McQueen 3

The cal. 11 “Chronomatic” movement inside was perhaps the first Swiss made automatic chronograph movement; the El Primero is the other candidate, while Seiko had its own on the other side of the world), all of which were introduced in 1969.

Heuer Monaco 1133B Steve McQueen 4

Distinguished by the crown on the left, the cal. 11 was a joint development between several brands, and was a last gasp of sorts for the mechanical chronograph before the Swiss watch industry went to hell in handbasket, carried along by the Quartz Crisis.

The Monaco is estimated at SFr12,000 to SFr18,000.

Lot 42 – Heuer Autavia Chronomatic “Siffert”

Introduced in 1969 as one of the debut models for the cal. 11 “Chronomatic” movement, the Autavia ref. 1163 was initially produced with “Chronomatic” on the dial. According to Phillips perhaps 50 to 100 such watches were made before the label was scrapped because it did not sell.

Heuer Autavia Siffert Chronomatic 1

Heuer Autavia Siffert Chronomatic 2

That production number encompassed various dial types for the Autavia, but arguably the most desirable is the variant in blue and white, nicknamed “Siffert” by collectors. This comes from the fact that 1960s Swiss racing driver Jo Siffert was often pictured with a similar watch.